Story of the Weeds: Canada Thistle

Story of the WeedsProject
Written By Info Farming Forward

Weed Name and Identification

Common name: Canada Thistle or Creeping Thistle
Scientific name: Cirsium arvense

This persistent perennial stands 30–100 cm tall, with spiny, lance-shaped leaves and small purple to pink flower heads clustered at the stem tops in summer. It spreads aggressively by wind-dispersed seeds and an extensive creeping root system that can reach over 2 m deep and extend outward up to 6 m. Even small root fragments can regenerate new shoots, making it very persistent.

What it Indicates About Soil

Canada Thistle tends to invade when pastures are stressed. Its presence suggests:

  • Moderately fertile, well-drained soils

  • Soil compaction or disturbed ground

  • Overgrazed or bare patches lacking strong forage competition

  • Imbalanced fertility, especially excess nitrogen without adequate plant cover

It thrives where pasture swards have weakened, often moving into gaps left by lost perennial forages. Once established, it quickly spreads and outcompetes more desirable species.

Ecological Role

As a pioneer species, Canada Thistle helps stabilize disturbed soils and offers nectar for pollinators and seeds for birds like goldfinches. However, it often forms dense colonies that reduce biodiversity, displace native plants, and create pest reservoirs. Its roots can exude allelopathic chemicals, further suppressing other plants.

Livestock Interaction

  • Palatability: Generally very low without intervention. Cattle and horses avoid it, while sheep and goats may graze young rosettes or regrowth before spines develop. However, research shows that cattle, sheep, and goats can be trained to eat Canada Thistle, especially when it is young and before it becomes spiny. With proper grazing management and training programs, livestock can help suppress thistle by targeting regrowth stages.

  • Nutritive Value: Can be comparable to alfalfa when grazed early, but is generally limited due to spines and low palatability. Under certain conditions (like high nitrogen or drought), it can accumulate nitrates and pose a risk if consumed in large quantities.

  • Impact on Pasture: Reduces usable forage, leads to uneven grazing patterns, and contributes to further pasture degradation over time.

”I have a different feeling about weeds than most people. That’s because I’ve turned them into forage.” - Kathy Voth*

Management and Replacement Strategies

Integrated management is essential. Combine tactics to weaken the weed while rebuilding soil health and pasture competition.

Soil & Pasture Management

  • Test soil and correct pH (liming if acidic) and nutrient imbalances

  • Improve organic matter with compost or manure to support stronger forage

  • Avoid overgrazing; use rotational grazing to maintain dense cover and root systems

  • Overseed to fill gaps and suppress regrowth

  • Balance nitrogen applications carefully to avoid favoring thistle

Grazing & Mechanical Control

  • Use targeted grazing with goats or sheep on young thistle growth, before spines harden

  • Mow at late bud stage before flowering to prevent seed set; repeat mowing multiple times per season over several years

  • If possible, mow just before rain. Freshly cut stems can absorb moisture, promoting rot and weakening regrowth.

  • Combine grazing and mowing to further stress the plant and deplete root reserves

Chemical Control

  • Apply selective herbicides (e.g., clopyralid, aminopyralid) in spring (rosette to early bolt stage) or in fall (regrowth stage when nutrients move to roots)

  • Use surfactants to improve herbicide absorption on waxy or hairy leaves

  • Expect to re-treat in subsequent years; always follow label directions and local guidelines

  • Combine chemical control with overseeding and soil improvements to prevent reinvasion

Follow label directions and local regulations, especially on public or Crown land.

Biological Control

Biocontrol options have been explored for Canada Thistle, though success varies by region and conditions:

  • Thistle stem weevil (Ceutorhynchus litura): Larvae feed inside stems, reducing plant vigor and potentially suppressing seed production.

  • Seed-head weevil (Larinus planus): Targets developing seeds, lowering seed output but not fully controlling established patches.

  • Thistle rust (Puccinia punctiformis): A naturally occurring fungus that infects roots and can weaken thistle stands over time. Rust can spread slowly and often requires specific conditions to establish. Read more here about Farming Forward’s Thistle Rust project.

Biological controls are generally best used as part of an integrated program rather than stand-alone solutions. Their effects are slow and usually support other strategies rather than replace them.

Recommended Replacement Forages

Once thistle is suppressed, reseed with species that are dense-rooted, competitive, and suited to Alberta’s conditions:

  • Alfalfa: Deep-rooted, high-protein legume that improves nitrogen levels and competes strongly once established. Excellent for hay or rotational grazing systems.

  • Sainfoin: Non-bloating legume option, useful in mixed stands and attracts pollinators.

  • Hybrid brome (e.g., AC Success): Long-lived, sod-forming grass that tolerates drought and heavy grazing.

  • Meadow brome or tall fescue: Productive, grazing-tolerant grasses that create dense swards to outcompete weeds.

  • Creeping red fescue or Kentucky bluegrass: For ground coverage in wet or compacted areas.

  • Chicory and plantain: Deep-rooted forbs that improve soil structure and help fill gaps quickly.

  • White clover and birdsfoot trefoil: Nitrogen-fixing legumes that improve fertility and provide palatable, high-quality forage.

Combining these species helps rebuild a resilient, productive pasture that resists future weed invasion and supports long-term soil health.

Sources and Further Reading

Info Farming Forward
Next

Accelerate Weekly #79